Is the arts sector built on the right theory of demand?
A theory of demand is a set of assumptions about why people choose to buy your product. It hypothesizes why demand exists and what drives it.
It’s invisible—but every organization is built on one. From that set of assumptions flow your value proposition, marketing, pricing, customer experience, and more.
So…if your underlying theory of demand is no longer aligned with consumer reality…yikes.
For much of the 20th century, we could reasonably operate from a product-centered theory of demand:
“People value our art form. Therefore, if we produce it at a high level and tell enough people about it, we’ll sell enough tickets.”
That theory depended on a particular set of conditions. But by the early 2000s, those conditions were dissolving.
Leisure alternatives multiplied, cultural authority fragmented, social rituals changed. Fewer people were brought up to believe that “going to the symphony/opera/ballet/theater/museum” was inherently worth doing.
That traditional theory of demand became misaligned with how consumers made choices.
The sector has worked hard to adapt. But one thing has remained largely untouched: its underlying theory of demand. So, most of that adaptation happened downstream:
Make the programming more contemporary.
Return to the classics.
Build a more impressive venue.
Get out of the traditional venue.
Hire a celebrity conductor.
Be more inclusive.
Lower ticket prices.
Make subscriptions more flexible.
Lowering ticket prices assumes people already want the art, and price is what stops them. Hiring a celebrity conductor assumes a bigger name will make the art more wanted.
All of these strategies still assume that demand begins with the art form. And that assumption restricts where we look for growth.
If we start with the art, we look for people who already love it. We ask how to make more people want it.
If we start with the people, we can ask a much bigger question: What demand already exists—and where could the arts become relevant to it?
That’s a very different way to think about demand. And it dramatically expands the number of people an organization could become relevant to.
Here’s a theory of demand built for today’s conditions:
“People do not begin by wanting an arts experience. They begin with circumstances in their lives, struggles they are trying to resolve, and outcomes they want. Demand emerges when an arts experience becomes relevant to that need.”
From “Who already likes our art?” to “Who is seeking the outcomes our art provides?”
When the world changes, it’s easy to change the things we can see: the programming, the venue, the pricing, the marketing. The logic underneath is where growth begins.
That’s the work I help arts organizations do.